VT VT
Home Past Shows Links Directions Auditions Membership About Us Box Office Fanmail 206 - 2007 Playbill

Reviews of
The Playboy of the Western World

A Wylde Irish Comedie
by J. M. Synge

The darker side of Irish blarney
Village Theatre does well with abrasive play
By Gary Smith
The Hamilton Spectator

 Kaz Novak, the Hamilton Spectator

Tanya Fraser, Charlene Gray, Claire Szatmari, Andrew Dundass and Rachel Steele star in Village Theatre Waterdown's Playboy of the Western World by J. M. Synge. The 1907 play explores the mystique behind the lighthearted Irish spirit and reveals the anger and fear that gurgles under the supposed Irish charm.

Don't expect leprechauns.

With Playboy Of The Western World, J.M. Synge takes an unsentimental look at the rambunctious nature of the roistering Irish.

Not only has the incorrigible Synge debunked the myth every Irishman is a latent poet, he has also expunged those foolish notions that brilliant blarney is the hefty cornerstone of every Irish romance.

If at the same time he has taken a disturbing look at festering violence, gurgling beneath the surface of benign calm, he has also displayed a healthy respect for the Irish fascination with myth-making.

That fact, almost more than any other, is what gives his 1907 play Playboy Of The Western World its audacious heart-pounding spirit.

What Synge has given us in his passionate play is the blacker heart of Irish blarney, something that surfaced generations later in the compelling dramas of countryman playwrights Martin McDonagh and Conor Macpherson.

Expect little of the poetic yearning associated with Brian Friel.

For all his soaring literary spirit, Synge is the natural father and dramatic conduit of darker Irish voices; voices that populate Dublin's Abbey Theatre now.

Playboy may be a beguiling story about an itinerant lad who flutters female hearts in a pub in County Mayo.

But this serious Irish comedy is more overtly and dramatically tied to an exploration of the vicious nature and predatory spirit of country folk.

The women flap like hungry chickens at the sight of this salty cock of the walk. And the men, a mostly pathetic lot, fear his unbridled spirit.

Causing riots when it opened in Dublin in January 1907, Playboy enraged audiences with its lack of romance. Its dark-hearted, unsympathetic view of women was particularly considered offensive.

With an erotic frisson of sexual tension between central characters Pegeen Mike and Christy Mahon, Playboy owed much to Synge's own sweaty passion for actress Molly Allgood.

And with clever manipulation and inflammatory spirit Synge took audiences close to the heart of what fickle celebrity and lost opportunity could mean.

Village Theatre Waterdown, under the watchful eye of director Mike Rae, gives us an appropriately abrasive staging of Synge's comedy.

Kelly Kimpton is riveting as feisty Pegeen Mike. Pulling back, she is capable of shimmering softly, then suddenly letting fly, soaring in musical flights of imagination manufactured in her quivering throat.

Bruce Edwards all but matches her as the vulgar, filth-stained Old Mahon, Synge's surprising and dramatic final trump card. And Brian Melanson, as feckless Shawn Keogh, a wimp of a thing, all but steals the show with his lip-pursing faces.

George Sanford and Tanya Fraser are excellent as a red-nosed booze-hound, and a randy young vixen, respectively.

Too bad Deborah Wyman, with her red-trimmed petticoat peeping beneath black mourning skirt, is too tame as man-hungry Widow Quin.

That brings us to Andrew Dundass' game go at Christy Mahon.

His delivery, loud and strong, substitutes too much surface rant for desperate feral passion. He gives a breathy punctuation point to almost every serious line. More importantly, he fails to suggest a powerful physical charisma that would send shockwaves of sexual energy to buoy restless female hearts.

There are several annoying quibbles. When Barbara Pepper has taken such pains with her evocative and splendid set, why does Dundass bed down on a rigid, slim bench? It's hardly believable.

Later, when he whacks his father with a shovel, why is there no blood on its pan?

After such pains have been taken to make Dundass dirty, why is his underwear, poking through the rents in his trousers, modern and clean?

And someone really needs to frisk every actor before allowing them on stage, removing facial jewellery, modern watches and anachronistic rings.

Realism can be shattered by the smallest detail.

Still, this Playboy is one of the best community theatre productions I've seen all season.

Fiddler Stephen Fuller, and the Manning Irish Dancers have helped to secure it in appropriate time and place.

Rae's gritty, Waterdown production, with its wildly beating heart, has clung to the dark side of Synge's tale.

That's why we don't see leprechauns. There's not a green man in sight.

 

Sally Panavas

View Magazine

Thirty years ago, a group of enthusiastic, young thespians decided that their community could use an infusion of theatrical culture. Eager to bring the magic of theatre to the township of Waterdown, the group became known as Waterdown Village Theatre, and began to stage plays for the community. To cap off their first season at the old Waterdown Memorial Hall, they staged a production of J.M Synge’s Irish comedy, The Playboy of the Western World. Three decades later, the director of Playboy has decided to give another try at staging the show that began his career with village theatre. For what better way is there to show how far the theatre company has come, than to improve upon past achievements?

            Although I was no more than a twinkle in my father’s eye when the first run of Playboy hit the Waterdown stage, the growth of the company is obvious with their encore production of the show. The theatre has achieved a new standard of professionalism, with new comfortable seating and a gallery of past performances. Yet, the presence of director Mike Rae greeting patrons at the door, suggests that Village Theatre has not lost touch with the community that has brought it fame. You can still feel the friendly, homemade ambiance of the theatre. Set designer Barbara Pepper has recreated the family owned pub that provides the setting for Playboy with meticulous creativity. From the barrels of ale littering the stage, to the wide beamed rafters and unfinished wooden furniture, nothing appears out of the historical context of Synge’s script. Costume designers Helen Davie and Helena Adamczyk are similarly successful in dressing the actors in simple, yet elegant period clothing. Amanda Fleet, the lighting designer, complements these elements with warm and subtle lighting.

            The story of Playboy is simple and entertaining. The small Irish town of Mayo is turned upside down with the arrival of Christy Mahon, played by Andrew Dundass. Mahon is a mysterious drifter who wins the hearts of several of the Mayo women with his tale of bravery and murder. However, it is Margaret Flaherty, played by Kelly Kimpton, who catches the eye of the “playboy.” She is the outspoken daughter of Michael James Flaherty, and fiancée of the sniveling Shawn Keogh (Brian Melanson). Conflict quickly explodes as Shawn battles for his beloved’s affection, and Margaret finds herself enticed by the boastful stranger.

            The cast of Playboy is of the caliber that I have come to expect from Village Theatre. Kelly Kimpton heads up a cast of strong performers, with her relaxed portrayal of Margaret. Among a strong cast, she stands out as an actor who is truly comfortable with both her dialect and character. Andrew Dundass is charming as the Playboy, using the wit of his character to win over the audience. Deborah Wyman is amusing in her role of the nosy widow Quin. However, it is the supporting cast that makes the world of Playboy believable. I find it remarkable that a cast of twelve people can carry off the challenging accent and dialect of the script. Even those in smaller roles give meaning to their lines, rather than allowing themselves to be bogged down by the Irish accent. The cast appears unified and familiar with each other, which is appropriate given the close relationship of their characters.

            Director Mike Rae has added small touches which make this production quite enjoyable. The audience is treated to gifted performances by the Manning Irish Dancers, and fiddler Stephen Fuller. The details are often what make or break a show, a fact that Mike Rae has eagerly embraced.

            For those of you who missed The Playboy of the Western World at Village Theatre in 1972, for whatever reason, here is your chance to experience the wonder of J.M Synge’s blarney comedy in all its glory. Stop bein’ a streeler and catch the next dray to Waterdown with yer da’ to see this tale of Irish puzzle-the-world!


© copyright 1972-2007
Web Design by Terrapin
Contact us